“New School is a flashpoint for what’s occurring. We’re a cautionary story,” New School of Florida gender research director Amy Reid informed Ms.
In January of 2023, New School of Florida in Sarasota was the state’s solely public liberal honors arts school, with a motto of “educating free thinkers, threat takers and trailblazers.” However a right-wing takeover has led to a mass exodus of professors and college students and violations of educational freedom and probably state legal guidelines.
The takeover of New School of Florida started on Jan. 6, 2023, when Governor Ron DeSantis appointed six new board members to vacant positions on the 13-member governing board of trustees of New School. The brand new members have been right-wing activists in tradition wars over schooling. Most had no connections to the school and even to the state of Florida.
One was Christopher Rufo, finest referred to as the architect of the anti-“essential race principle” motion.
One other was Matthew Spalding, a dean at Hillsdale School, a personal Christian school in Michigan recognized for its non secular conservatism. On the day of the takeover, DeSantis’ chief of workers expressed “hope that New School of Florida will turn out to be Florida’s classical school, extra alongside the traces of a Hillsdale of the South.”
DeSantis additionally appointed Charles Kesler, a member of the Claremont Institute who helped to construct Trump’s 1776 Fee, and Ryan T. Anderson, president of the right-wing suppose tank Ethics & Public Coverage Heart. All had ties to right-wing suppose tanks and coverage organizations, reminiscent of The Manhattan Institute and The Heritage Basis.
On Jan. 31 of that 12 months, the New School of Florida board of trustees voted to terminate president Patricia Okker—the primary feminine president of the school—and shortly after appointed a brand new interim president, former Florida cducation commissioner Richard Corcoran, an advocate of vouchers and constitution colleges.
In response, professors left New School in droves. Thirty-six professors—one-third of the school—left post-takeover. In April 2023, the board of trustees denied tenure to all 5 candidates with no rationalization. In 2024, one other 12 professors left the school.
Many college students left as effectively. By September 2023, over three dozen college students moved to Massachusetts-based Hampshire School, which provided switch admission to New School college students in good standing. Extra adopted within the spring. (New School has lower than 700 college students enrolled, the smallest scholar inhabitants within the state college system of Florida.)
Undeterred, the brand new management imposed radical adjustments to campus, voting to get rid of the variety, fairness and inclusion workplace and the gender research program. By Might of 2023, the gender-neutral restroom indicators have been ripped down and murals celebrating variety painted over. New School started recruiting athletes for newly-formed sports activities groups and despatched out a survey proposing doable new mascots, together with on the record “The Rebels” and “Conquistadors.” The varsity lowered its admission requirements: The brand new admits had considerably decrease common GPA and standardized check scores than earlier first-years. Incoming athletes have been assigned to newer dorms, whereas returning college students have been assigned to dorms that had critical mould issues. Ultimately, a lot of the returning college students have been housed in off-campus motels. In August of 2023, Inside Larger Training summed up the scenario in an article titled, “Chaos at New School of Florida.”
On the identical time, New School acquired $2 million from the Florida legislature to fund the New School Freedom Institute to supposedly battle again towards a “large cancel tradition” at faculties and universities. In June 2024, the school hosted a symposium titled “Reversing the Ideological Seize of Universities and Establishments” with Trump COVID adviser Scott Atlas, who advocated the disastrous “herd immunity” strategy to the pandemic.
With Undertaking 2025 promising to do to larger schooling throughout the nation what DeSantis has accomplished to New School of Florida, Ms. sat down with New School professor Amy Reid to debate how the school has modified because the takeover, and the way college are combating again.
Reid joined the school at New School as a French professor in 1995 and helped develop the gender research program on the school. After the takeover, her friends elected her chair of the school, making her a member of the board of trustees.
Carrie Baker: What was New School like earlier than the takeover?
Amy Reid: Due to the pandemic, like many different small liberal arts faculties, we have been in a really weakened state, unprepared for what occurred on January 6, 2023. We have been going through actual constraints by way of our finances, and we have been going through an more and more hostile setting from the state.
However we additionally had some purpose for optimism. We had simply employed Pat Okker as our new president, and she or he appeared to be bringing some savvy about each inner and exterior relations that we would have liked. And she or he understood and was dedicated to the liberal arts in a means that was actually necessary and inspiring to school and college students.
Baker: What led to the takeover?
Reid: Numerous issues had occurred on a statewide degree even earlier than the takeover, like a tightening noose for larger schooling within the state of Florida.
In 2021, the legislature handed Home Invoice 233, the “viewpoint safety” invoice, which allowed college students to report college surreptitiously in the event that they wished to file a criticism towards you. We understood this as a means of breaking the bond of belief that’s vital for schooling.
Baker: How did this regulation have an effect on your instructing?
Reid: We acquired steerage from the union about reminding college students that whereas they’re allowed to report lectures, they’re not allowed to report their fellow college students or discussions. We have been suggested that if our class was discussion-based, which most of our courses are, to placed on the syllabus that it was a discussion-based class and so couldn’t be recorded. The union despatched us boiler-plate language.
Larger schooling shouldn’t simply be funneling individuals in direction of a slim profession objective, however about increasing your horizons, taking off your blinders.
Amy Reid
Baker: What different legal guidelines did they move that impacted New School?
Reid: In 2022, they handed the Cease WOKE and Don’t Say Homosexual Acts. Don’t Say Homosexual focuses totally on Okay-12, however Cease WOKE has provisions that concerned employment, schooling, Okay-12 and better schooling. The regulation bans employers from having variety coaching and limits discussions of divisive matters.
Then in 2023, they handed Home Invoice 1521, which is the trans rest room ban, and Senate Invoice 266, which prohibits all use of state funds for DEI or to “promote activism” in larger schooling. At that time, members of our new board of trustees argued publicly that the sphere gender research was not tutorial however activist. We began to see how the legislators and the forces represented on our board of trustees have been working in live performance.
Senate Invoice 266, which was signed into regulation on the NCF campus in Might 2023, particularly prohibits instructing theories that “systemic racism, sexism, oppression and privilege are inherent within the establishments of america.” The regulation additionally requires that humanities programs normally schooling curricula throughout the state embody the Western canon. My particular subject of experience is in African and Francophone literatures. In order that meant, in a single fell swoop, that my courses that had at all times been a part of our basic schooling curriculum might now not be, except I used to be going to start out including within the Western canon to programs on African or Caribbean literature. My class on post-colonial African literature might embody a number of Nobel winners and Booker Prize winners, actually necessary authors, and but it wouldn’t depend.
Additionally they took away quite a lot of tenure protections, together with the fitting to office arbitration for college, so in the event you’re denied tenure, the one particular person you may attraction that call to is the one who denied you tenure within the first place: the president of the establishment. You’ll be able to’t have an outdoor particular person contemplate the case. They’re eviscerating any form of employment rights for college. The state has even gone as far as to argue in its protection of “Cease WOKE” that college haven’t any rights to free speech, however are restricted to “authorities speech”—that means concepts endorsed by the state. The implications of this are dystopian.
Baker: How did college reply to those adjustments?
Reid: Already in 2022, it began to really feel like a disaster was looming, so we deliberate a gender research college retreat for January 2023. Then I went to the Nationwide Ladies’s Research Affiliation convention in November of 2023 and there was a panel speaking about points in Florida with Diane Value Herndl from USF, Nikki Morse from FAU and others. That was the second once I realized what we would have liked to deal with head-on the problems of censorship coming from the state. I reached out to my colleagues again residence and our college union. We deliberate a day-long workshop to speak about what it means to be instructing about race and gender in Florida now. We had scheduled it for the third week in January, after which January 6 occurred, and so our day-long workshop was all of the extra necessary as a result of we have been proper then at a disaster second. A couple of third of New School college—from Humanities, Social and Pure Sciences—took half within the workshop.
Baker: Was DeSantis’ Jan. 6 announcement a shock?
Reid: For many of us, sure, it was completely out of the blue, however I believe the administration had some heads-up about it.
Baker: Are board members often political appointees with no affiliation to the school or is it usually accomplished in session with the school administration or college?
Reid: The boards of trustees for all the colleges have been remade quite a few years in the past to incorporate extra state-chosen nominees. They’re accredited by the state legislature.
Baker: Had been the six that have been appointed totally different from earlier appointments of their lack of connection to the school or to the sphere of schooling?
Reid: Sure, as a result of they have been primarily not from Florida. Most haven’t any connection to New School, and a number of other haven’t any tutorial expertise. Christopher Rufo only a political operative. Spaulding and Bauerlein are within the right-wing tutorial sphere. Bauerlein is a retired professor from Emory. Spaulding is a part of Hillsdale School. They usually introduced in Ryan Anderson, who’s at The Heritage Basis. They’d Eddie Speir, who was an area man, however with views so excessive the legislature wouldn’t even approve his nomination. They’d one New School alum, Debra Jenks, who they introduced in to be the chair. However a lot of the new board members had no connection to New School. Speir and Jenks have been the one two who had Florida residency.
Chris Rufo was very clear that college students and school who didn’t like this might depart, might ‘self-select out.’
Amy Reid
Baker: What adjustments occurred when these individuals joined the board?
Reid: They instantly fired the president. Then they introduced that Richard Corcoran can be the brand new interim president. Information of his appointment was circulated earlier than the board met, which raised questions on a doable violation of Florida Sunshine Legal guidelines. As commissioner of schooling, Corcoran was answerable for growing the federal government assist of personal colleges and voucher packages throughout the state. He has quite a lot of connections to the constitution faculty motion.
Baker: What did they do after they appointed Corcoran?
Reid: They shut down our DEI workplace. They fired Yoleidy Rosario-Hernandez, a queer particular person of shade who directed the workplace. Chris Rufo was very clear that college students and school who didn’t like this might depart, might “self-select out.” They proceeded to fireside quite a few different individuals, concentrating on ladies and other people of shade, though not completely, changing professionals with individuals with political connections, typically with little or no experience or expertise in larger schooling. They introduced that they have been going to eliminate the gender research program. They closed down the Pleasure dorm and threw out the books from the Pleasure library.
To manage college, they halted the tenure course of. There have been seven individuals who had been accredited by all ranges of tenure evaluation aside from a remaining vote by the board of trustees. They shut that down. Corcoran satisfied two of the seven individuals accredited for tenure to withdraw their candidacies, and the 5 individuals who went up for tenure have been all summarily denied. That actually signaled to school that we weren’t going to be in cost. Corcoran additionally shut down all discretionary spending.
Baker: How did you get a seat on the board of trustees?
Reid: On the assembly the place they denied college tenure, the school chair Matt Lepinski resigned from the board of trustees and stop the school. I used to be elected to fill his seat. Due to my place as the pinnacle of gender research and as a tenured college member, I had been talking out on behalf of the school since January. I used to be additionally a part of a gaggle of school members who have been named to an emergency coordinating committee for the union in order that we might reply to every part that was occurring on campus. When Matt Lepinski stepped down, totally different individuals requested me to run to be chair of the school. So, in June of 2023, I joined the board of trustees.
Baker: In order that they have been making an attempt to eliminate gender research, however then the gender research director finally ends up on the board of trustees. They have been most likely not pleased about that!
Reid: No. They weren’t.
Baker: What has it been like at board conferences with these new members?
Reid: It’s been terrible. I’m recurrently dismissed. When it’s on zoom, I’ve my mic reduce off. I’ve been known as “petty and performative” and in a single assembly, Christopher Rufo informed me to “simply shut up.” I persistently learn the budgets and lift critical questions in regards to the monetary oversight of this faculty. They don’t need that. The infantile insults they lob at me are unbelievable.
Baker: Are they monitoring your syllabi?
Reid: For any course that’s a part of the overall schooling curriculum, the state requires that you simply submit your syllabus and it turns into a part of a publicly searchable database for 5 years. That is a part of the chilling setting that was in place earlier than. There have been quite a lot of interim steps about textbook evaluation, and handing over your syllabi, that have been making Florida a extra hostile place to show, making a chilling setting for college and college students. The state’s latest requirement is that each one syllabi be looked for phrases together with “Israel,” “Palestine” and “Judaism,” purportedly to determine antisemitism—it’s actually a witch hunt.
I stayed out of dedication to this place and its college students.
Amy Reid
Baker: Are there different issues making a chilling setting?
Reid: They’ve searched individuals’s emails. There’s been censorship of emails on campus. That’s been an enormous situation. After the trans rest room ban handed in 2023, the administration began renaming all of our unisex loos on campus. If the signal mentioned gender-neutral rest room, it was taken down. We had a multi-stall rest room with an indication indicating it was open for everyone, and that signal was taken down. In some locations, they put up indicators that mentioned women and men. Elsewhere, there’s nonetheless simply torn plaster the place the indicators was. That’s seen and hostile defacing of our campus.
Then a university official despatched out a memo to all people—college, college students and workers—explaining the trans rest room ban and that individuals had to make use of the toilet that corresponds to your delivery certificates and that if you’re requested to depart a toilet and you don’t, then you’re topic to punishment underneath the scholar code. However it even went additional, suggesting that college must be policing the loos.
Three of us from college management wrote a response saying the regulation doesn’t require anyone to implement this regulation, that there was no college rest room patrol. We despatched our memo to all people who’d gotten the preliminary memo—college, college students and workers—nevertheless it solely went out to school. Our e mail was blocked from going to college students and workers. I had college students and workers flow into it on the facet for us, however the administration by no means let our message go to the entire campus group. They usually by no means responded to our requests that they make clear that there isn’t a authorized requirement that college patrol the loos and that they flow into a map exhibiting the place gender-neutral loos are on campus.
Baker: What number of college members left after the takeover?
Reid: Out of roughly 100 college members, over 30 left the school in 2023, together with individuals who retired, took early retirement, sought different employment, walked away, or have been visiting and never renewed. Except a few retirees, these have been all individuals we had anticipated to be instructing the following 12 months. My three closest colleagues all left. Nick Clarkson, who’s the one gender research professor, resigned very publicly. Ms. revealed his letter of resignation a 12 months in the past. One other 12 of us are leaving this 12 months.
Baker: Why did you keep?
Reid: I stayed out of dedication to this place and its college students. Then I took the job as college chair, which principally meant a dedication to doing that. I labored as onerous as I might. For the previous 12 months and a half, I’ve been engaged on our campus, on the board of trustees, and in statewide organizations to assist actually high-quality public schooling, the ideas of educational freedom and the values of DEI.
Final spring, I began searching for different employment as a result of I noticed I couldn’t keep. I discovered a job with PEN America, the place I’ll be working with the Freedom to Be taught workforce, which permits me to proceed the work that I’ve been doing for the previous 12 months and a half at New School in a broader body. I hope that I can take the hard-fought classes I’ve discovered over the previous years to assist forestall these broad assaults on larger schooling and public schooling throughout the nation.
Baker: How do you outline tutorial freedom?
Reid: Tutorial freedom is about making certain that college can train and that college students turn out to be energetic and engaged learners, energetic and engaged residents for his or her lifetime. Larger schooling shouldn’t simply be funneling individuals in direction of a slim profession objective, however about increasing your horizons, taking off your blinders.
Baker: Do you suppose New School is turning into extra vocational and fewer a couple of broad liberal arts schooling that teaches them to suppose and interact totally different views?
Reid: Throughout the state of Florida, the legislature and the board of governors are encouraging schooling for jobs, not schooling as a price in and of itself. Florida has had, till not too long ago, top-of-the-line state techniques for larger schooling. We’ve truly been ranked first within the nation for a few years. I believe that’s going to be shifting, sadly.
Baker: Is it more durable to rent good college now?
Reid: These statewide initiatives are driving away college and college students. The hiring course of has turn out to be politicized. Lots of people don’t and won’t apply to jobs in Florida anymore. Then you definitely add onto that sure litmus assessments that appear to be utilized. New School college have labored actually onerous for this previous 12 months to fill college vacancies in probably the most moral means doable, however some hiring selections appear to replicate an ideological agenda. For instance, the hiring of Bruce Gilley, who appears to suppose that his job description contains attacking the New School college, as a presidential scholar. How weird that President Corcoran provided him a place when Gilley writes items within the conservative blogosphere insulting New School college.
Baker: What has been the affect of the takeover on college students?
Reid: You’ll be able to think about what it means when a 3rd of the school depart. College students are unable to finish their areas of focus and senior theses. We’ve had important departures in fields starting from biology, chemistry and physics to sociology, political science, psychology, literature and gender research.
Baker: Are college students leaving too?
Reid: We misplaced quite a lot of college students. We’ve had a big queer presence on campus and now college students must suppose twice about even utilizing the toilet. The brand new administration has recruited giant incoming courses of primarily athletes. They’re people who find themselves coming right here to play sports activities slightly than to review, and that has unfavorable penalties for the educational program. Final 12 months we had over 70 baseball gamers on campus. The College of Florida has about half that quantity on their baseball roster. This 12 months, they’ve recruited at the least 75 international athletes, together with upwards of 30 soccer gamers from Brazil—that’s going to be an enormous workforce. A number of the college students are transferring from different non secular faculties. Many of the coaches that they’ve employed have labored at locations like Bob Jones College and Liberty College.
Final 12 months, once we had issues with the dorms, the administration selected to deal with the issues in ways in which made it clear that our persevering with college students weren’t wished. They kicked nearly all of the returning college students into off-campus motels. These are college students who’d already acquired on-campus housing assignments, however they have been put in motels and the first-year athletes have been put into the dorms that had historically been for upper-class college students. This 12 months, they’ve truly put up a complete bunch of short-term dormitories that appear like storage containers on the soft-ball subject!
Baker: Are there extra male college students on campus now?
Reid: Whereas we have no idea what the ratio of male to feminine college students is for the incoming class, final 12 months was the primary time in all my years at NCF that we had a majority male incoming class and, because of this, a majority of male college students on campus. I anticipate that to be an growing development this 12 months, when a lot of the incoming class is comprised of athletic recruits. Up to now, like most liberal arts faculties, we’d had a majority of female-identified college students—between 65 and 69 % lately, which is in keeping with different related colleges.
Parallel to that the administration simply despatched us a booklet with profiles of the brand new college. Of the 45 listed, I believe seven are feminine. So at the least 80 % are male, perhaps extra. That’s beautiful.
Baker: Are you seeing non secular occasions and prayers on campus?
Reid: Final spring, former trustee Eddie Speir had a mass baptism of scholars on our campus and posted a video about it. Our athletic director talks very explicitly about his non secular mission. They’ve employed two totally different firms to run the on-campus espresso store that had beforehand been run by college students—each have been religiously affiliated. There have been complaints about them passing out cups with non secular messages on them and taking part in movies of non secular music. When individuals have state contracts which might be subsidizing them to run a espresso store, that’s a misuse of state funds.
Baker: Do you may have any hope for New School?
Reid: It’s onerous to know what’s going to occur. This coming 12 months goes to robust. We could hit a tipping level for New School this 12 months, however there are nonetheless college who’re staying, who’re extremely devoted and dealing actually onerous to assist our college students and to proceed to offer a invaluable instructional expertise for the scholars right here. That offers me hope.
Baker: How are you holding up?
Reid: For the reason that takeover, it’s felt like combating the hydra as a result of as you concentrate on one battle, there’s at all times eight different arms coming round. So I look to Molly Ivins for encouragement: “Hold fightin’ for freedom and justice, beloveds, however don’t you overlook to have enjoyable doin’ it.”
Ms. Classroom desires to listen to from educators and college students being impacted by laws attacking public schooling, larger schooling, gender, race and sexuality research, activism and social justice in schooling, and variety, fairness and inclusion packages for our collection, ‘Banned! Voices from the Classroom.’ Submit pitches and/or op-eds and reflections (between 500-800 phrases) to Ms. contributing editor Aviva Dove-Viebahn at adove-viebahn@msmagazine.com. Posts will likely be accepted on a rolling foundation.
Up subsequent:
U.S. democracy is at a harmful inflection level—from the demise of abortion rights, to an absence of pay fairness and parental depart, to skyrocketing maternal mortality, and assaults on trans well being. Left unchecked, these crises will result in wider gaps in political participation and illustration. For 50 years, Ms. has been forging feminist journalism—reporting, rebelling and truth-telling from the front-lines, championing the Equal Rights Modification, and centering the tales of these most impacted. With all that’s at stake for equality, we’re redoubling our dedication for the following 50 years. In flip, we want your assist, Assist Ms. in the present day with a donation—any quantity that’s significant to you. For as little as $5 every month, you’ll obtain the print journal together with our e-newsletters, motion alerts, and invites to Ms. Studios occasions and podcasts. We’re grateful in your loyalty and ferocity.
